System to redraw Utah districts meets ballot threshold

Members of the Utah House work on the floor during a special session at the state Capitol in Salt Lake City, Utah, April 18, 2018. A ballot initiative that would create a new system for drawing Utah's state legislative and congressional districts has met the threshold to be placed before voters in November. | Associated Press file photo by Rick Bowmer, St. George News

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — A ballot initiative that would create a new system for drawing Utah’s state legislative and congressional districts has met the threshold to be placed before voters in November.

An updated count of verified signatures posted by Utah’s lieutenant governor’s office shows the so-called Better Boundaries initiative should qualify for the ballot. Results are not official until they’ve been certified by the lieutenant governor next month.

If approved by voters, the new initiative would create a seven-member bipartisan commission to redraw state districts to specific standards following the 2020 census. Lawmakers would then vote to approve or reject the new maps.

“We believe that voters should be picking their politicians and not the other way around, that is the politicians picking their voters,” Ralph Becker said, co-chair of the Better Boundaries Coalition.

Critics of the state’s current system say that the overwhelmingly Republican Legislature has gerrymandered districts to reduce the number of competitive races and allow politicians to ignore their constituents. An analysis of state legislative districts by The Associated Press last June found that the state’s map may have benefited Republicans.

Republican Gov. Gary Herbert has said there’s “certainly intellectually good sense to” the reform.

“It’s not going to be exactly the silver bullet that everybody thinks it’s going to be, but I have no opposition to independent redistricting,” he told reporters last month.

Better Boundaries campaign manager Catherine Kanter said supporters were pleased to have reached the preliminary threshold.

Opponents of the measure worry it takes too much power away from the state legislature, which currently draws the districts.

Outgoing Utah House Speaker Greg Hughes’ office has called redistricting “a fundamental duty of the Legislature.”

With the initiative, Utah is part of a nationwide trend of states eyeing changes to the redistricting process ahead of the 2020 census. More than 400 House districts and nearly 7,400 state legislative districts will be redrawn following the census, and at least 18 states have grappled with reforming how that will happen.

The threshold reached Thursday means that all four of Utah’s closely-watched ballot initiatives are expected to be presented to voters in November. Data from the lieutenant governor’s office has previously shown that questions should also qualify on medical marijuana, expanding Medicaid and making it easier for political candidates to bypass party conventions.

Opponents of some of those initiatives are hoping to block them from reaching the ballot by using the final days before certification to convince voters to withdraw their names from petitions.

Written by JULIAN HATTEM, Associated Press

Email: [email protected]

Twitter: @STGnews

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!


  • tcrider May 12, 2018 at 1:06 pm

    I cannot believe the opposition to the petition went as far as it did, what about the first amendment? (separation of church and state),
    There is sure a lot of support for the second amendment, but when it comes to the first amendment, there seems to be a lot of self-
    Like so many far right opinions and ideas, there seems to be a lot of fear based bias and lies, and I am not say the far left is any better,
    but there is not as much of the fear based bs.

  • Waid May 13, 2018 at 1:09 pm

    Republicans are scared … by any form of unbiased redistricting. Their primary legislative power now derives from gerrymandering district boundaries to shut out any possibility of a Democrat winning an election. They’ve been extremely successful at doing that, and at suppressing the votes of every class of citizen who might not be inclined to vote conservative. For Republican legislators, it’s not about doing what’s right for their constituents, but merely about winning — retaining their power, prestige, and the boatloads of money (bribes) rolling in from their wealthy conservative benefactors.

    Ed. Ellipsis.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.