St. George council candidates discuss growth, code enforcement, short-term rentals

L-R: Top: St. George City Council candidates Joe Bowcutt and Greg Aldred. Bottom: Michele Randall and Greg McArthur. | Photos sumbmitted, composite by St. George News

ST. GEORGE – While the challenges presented by the city’s continuing growth are among major issues discussed during election time, others issues also persist. Among those in St. George are concerns over code enforcement and short-term rentals.

These issues were the focus of three questions asked of the candidates for St. George City Council: incumbents Michele Randall and Joe Bowcutt, and challengers Gregg McArthur and Greg Aldred.

Read more: Mayor’s race: Pike calls for growth planning; Ronnow says residents must be heard

Downtown St. George, Utah, March 5, 2016 | Photo by Mori Kessler, St. George News

It’s no secret St. George and Washington County overall are growing. The county’s growth rate rose to nearly 4 percent in 2016 according to a recent study from the University of Utah’s Kem C. Gardner Policy Institute. The county’s current population is over 150,000 and is projected to reach 321,000 by 2040


So what do the candidates say are the most pressing issues the city faces related to that growth?

“Water, infrastructure and traffic,” Bowcutt said. “Those are the challenges we face.”

Randal agreed, adding that providing for the public safety of the city’s citizens is also paramount.

“With an increased population, we have to keep up with the demands on public safety; our police department and fire department,” Randal said. “We need to have the personnel and equipment to help them keep our neighborhoods safe.”

Both Randal and Bowcutt also said city infrastructure is getting older and will ultimately need to be replaced. However, a steady revenue structure, particularly in the case of road maintenance, needs to be found.

While providing that future infrastructure is important, McArthur said it requires study and planning that should involve city residents.

“I think we need to more effectively inform and collect better input and feedback from the citizens on the future planning and infrastructure projects that are proposed for our community,” he said.

Mall Drive on the east side of the Virgin River, St. George, May 24, 2016 | Photo by Mori Kessler, St. George News

“For us to continue the growth, we need affordable housing,” Aldred said.

Aldred didn’t necessarily mean subsidized housing either, he said, but rather homes affordable for young people and those moving to St. George for work.

The city may be looking at a possible labor shortage if the people who want to move here for work or stay here and work end up having nowhere affordable they can reside.

“It’s a formula for failure with that growth,” he said.

As for water, conservation of water is needed in conjunction with the Lake Powell Pipeline, Bowcutt said. Speaking to the cost of the pipeline, however, Bowcutt said the state and federal government should help fund the project. Local funding just won’t be enough, he said.

Randall and McArthur also support the concept of the Lake Powell Pipeline, as well as conservation while also securing alternative water sources.

While not necessarily opposed to the Lake Powell Pipeline, Aldred has said St. George should consider the alternative of striking a deal with Nevada to get water piped in from the Snake Valley.

Code enforcement

St. George has also been reviewing its ordinances in recent years and is working with an outside consultant to identify areas of potential reform. Do the candidates think the city has done enough in this area? Not so much. The process is ongoing and certain areas remain in need of review and updating, they said.

Photo from the St. George city code enforcement website depicting an example of clear city code violations at a residence, date and location not specified | Photo courtesy of the city of St. George, St. George News

“We still have work to do on our codes and ordinances,” Randall said. “As an example, I personally want to see the code regarding unregistered vehicles gone forever. I don’t care if you have an unregistered vehicle parked at your home.”

Specific pieces of city code Bowcutt wants to see revamped and modernized involve the city’s sign and conditional use permit ordinances.

Like Randall, McArthur also supports doing away with city code that doesn’t work.

“Let’s keep the ones that are relevant and let’s get rid of the ones that do not make sense,” McArthur said, adding he supports city code in general because it helps keep St. George “a beautiful and clean town.”

In relation to the city’s code enforcement officers, McArthur said they should “respect personal property rights and that they should be well trained in customer service.”

The code enforcement officers also should not be roaming the streets and actively looking for code violations, Aldred said. Instead, it should be left to the citizens to call the city with their complaints and for the city to respond accordingly, he said.

Short-term rentals

One of the major ordinance issues the city faces pertains to short-term rentals. The city has prohibited short-term rentals in residential neighborhoods due to disruptions and nuisances they allegedly create.

Individuals involved in homeowner-occupied situations – that is when the homeowner is living in the home and renting a part of it out to tourists – say concerns that city officials and some neighbors have are overblown.

Short-term rentals should not be in residential neighborhoods where they are not zoned,” Bowcutt said.

The city already has 12 areas that are zoned for short-term rentals, he said.

“I do not have an issue with owner-occupied short-term rentals,” Randal said, “If the homeowner is present, they take pride in ownership and they are concerned about their neighbors.”

However, she does take issue of short-term rentals run by out-of-town investors who advertise the homes as places where up to 40 people or more can stay.

We have had many neighborhoods where an entire charter bus pulls up to the rental home, or visiting sports teams, and so on,” Randall said. “The investor doesn’t care about the neighbors, or their concerns. Most likely they have never even met the neighbors. I believe neighborhoods are for neighbors.”

McArthur agrees with the city’s current policies for short-term rentals. However, longtime residents and potential homebuyers should also be able to say how their neighborhoods handle short-term rentals.

Both Bowcutt and McArthur said regulations governing short-term rentals are best handled at the local level, and not by the state.

“I did not agree with the bill that was proposed at the Utah Legislature this last season which proposed regulating this at the state level,” McArthus said. “Our local governments know our communities the best and should be able to make these decisions on a local level.”

Aldred has a differing opinion.

Homeowner-occupied short-term rentals should be allowed in the city as long as they meet certain criteria, Aldred said. This includes getting approval from surrounding neighbors, abiding by city ordinances that prevent basic nuisances and paying a room tax like hotels do.

“We, as a City Council, should be able to make rules that are fair for the people,” Aldred said,

If the city continues to deny homeowners the ability to use their homes as short-term rentals, Aldred said he is in favor of the state stepping in.

The general election is set for Nov. 7.

Email: [email protected]

Twitter: @MoriKessler

Copyright St. George News, LLC, 2017, all rights reserved.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!


  • tcrider October 4, 2017 at 8:54 pm

    Randall McArthur

    Your idea of letting a home owner do short term rentals is highly flawed because it creates a double standard of having
    a out of town home owner do a long term rental in one part of the home and doing short term rentals in other parts of the home, while the home owner doesn’t even live in it, and believe it or not, the neighbors are paying taxes to live in a single residence neighborhood.
    It would be a cool idea and incentive to charge large fines for violators and split the money with the city and the people turning in these violators.

  • utahdiablo October 4, 2017 at 11:29 pm

    Short term renters don’t give a crap about the neighborhood, where they park their toys, or their noise or the people who live there full time, who have their entire lives and family tied into what was supposed to be a single family / non nightly rental area….If we wanted to live next to a Hotel, we would have moved next to a Hotel….How many of you are being paid off to pass whatever your “Masters” want over the needs of the citizens of your cities?….stop your damn Greed City Council members or members to be…POS

  • mmsandie October 5, 2017 at 8:58 am

    Randall is wr9ng, I didn,5 vote for her seeing she owed taxes 5o the city from her ambulance company and then closed i5 down..ignoring unlicensed vehicles in a yar$ is wrong! They could be stolen, I know of one house that has 8 cars and trucks or more in their yard without licenses and it look like a selvage yard and it’s in. Bloomington short term rentals in residential neighborhoods with absentee landlords is a big problem, when I visit m6 friend in Bloomington, and i use a cane..I have to walk a distance to get in her house, they bloc’ her driveway with their toys.. it’s a big problem.. if you get 200-400 dollars a night the homeowner doesn.t care about a fine from the city …

  • freetochoose October 5, 2017 at 4:34 pm

    I don’t think anyone moves into a neighborhood thinking they’ll be moving next to an unsupervised hotel. Yes, it’s America, yes you have a right to open a hospitality business, but not if it zoned single family residential.

  • Mike October 6, 2017 at 10:50 pm

    I love these statements by Mr. Allred:
    “For us to continue the growth, we need affordable housing,” Aldred said.

    Aldred didn’t necessarily mean subsidized housing either, he said, but rather homes affordable for young people and those moving to St. George for work.

    The city may be looking at a possible labor shortage if the people who want to move here for work or stay here and work end up having nowhere affordable they can reside.

    Think about all the SERVICE WORKERS for the new hotels and restaurants coming to town to help accommodate the tourists and visitors of all our events. Where are these LOWER PAID WORKERS going to live? With little to no affordable housing, you WILL see a labor shortage!! Then what?

    Even our school teachers, fire, police, and government employees are affected by the high rent. Employers are going to need to step up and help their employees with housing or they may not have the personnel to keep their businesses profitable.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.