BLM asks commission to narrow its records request

Iron County Commission April 2015 St. George News
From L-R: Iron County Commissioners Casey Anderson (interim commissioner), Alma Adams and Dale Brinkerhoff; Deputy County Attorney Mike Edwards. The commission meeting Monday included a discussion about the Bureau of Land Management's response to its request under the Freedom of Information Act, suggesting they narrow their request to avoid a voluminous document production. Iron County Commission chambers. Parowan, Utah, April 25, 2016 | Photo by Tracie Sullivan, St. George News / Cedar City News

PAROWAN – A Bureau of Land Management representative has asked the Iron County Commissioners via a letter to narrow the scope of a 2015 records request saying it will result in “thousands of pages of material.”

One commissioner, however, isn’t too concerned about the number of pages the agency will have to come up with.

I’m not real sympathetic to their plight,” Commissioner Dale Brinkerhoff said during Monday’s commission meeting.

The Iron County Commission and others submitted their request to the BLM under the authority of the Freedom of Information Act, which entitles the public to access records and information from any federal agency, with some exceptions.

The 2015 request seeks, in part, any communications between representatives of the BLM and nongovernmental organizations, specifically environmental groups, from January 2013 to the present.

Commissioner Alma Adams said it would be illegal for the NGOs to meet or communicate with the BLM privately, including through emails.

“They should only receive written or verbal comments, comments in a public meeting if they have one,” Adams said. “They should never be meeting at any time, including through email, to discuss decisions with NGOs. Under the law they (the BLM) have to coordinate with us, but there is nothing under the law that says they have to coordinate with those groups.”

The commissioners’ biggest concern is that they have done just this, Adams added.

BLM Color Country District Manager Heather Whittman’s wrote a letter to the commission, which the commissioners discussed during their Monday meeting. In the letter, Whittman said they would be more likely to get what they are looking for in their request if it was more specific.

“If you provide additional specificity in your request, you are more likely to get the actual documents you are seeking versus thousands of pages which may not contain useful information,” Whittman stated.

The FOIA request has already produced an initial release of documents totaling more than 10,000 pages, Commissioner Alma Adams said.

Interim Commissioner Casey Anderson said he is concerned about how the county would deal with the documents, once received.

“Mike Edwards (deputy county attorney, present at the meeting) isn’t going to be able to review those by himself,” Anderson said. “Then we’re looking at additional personnel in order to review the documents. I’m just trying to look at execution.”

Since the FOIA document was part of a group request between several counties who all wanted the same information, Brinkerhoff said he didn’t want to make any decisions without first consulting the different commissioners. Anderson and Adams agreed.

Iron County Clerk Jon Whittaker told the group Monday that former Commissioner Dave Miller, who resigned in March, had asked him to submit the request in December 2015.

The request asks the BLM for all communications between employees in the BLM Color Country Office and various NGOs. Among the NGOs listed are the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, Grand Canyon Trust and the Western Watershed Project.

The records request also asks for any communications during that same time period, January 2013 to the present, “involving, mentioning, or including” any county commissioners in Washington, Iron, Garfield, Beaver, San Juan, Sevier, Wayne, Piute or Kane counties.

Besides NGOs, the document requests all communications between Whittman and her husband Chris Zinda.

Zinda has been an opponent of the commissioners since last year when he publicly criticized them for spending taxpayer’s money on the Western Freedom Festival, an event he said had a political and religious agenda.

The commissioners specifically asked for communication concerning issues on the wild horse and burro program, RS2477 roads (roads open for public use regardless of ownership issues), sage grouse, energy product and the 2010 Western Freedom Festival.

The BLM Color Country District Office could not be reached for comment as of publication time.

Email: [email protected]

Twitter: @tracie_sullivan

Copyright St. George News, LLC, 2016, all rights reserved.


Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!

1 Comment

  • anybody home April 26, 2016 at 2:59 pm

    When people like the Iron County don’t know what they want, they use this kind of shotgun approach with regard to information and then don’t know what to do with it when they get it. Frankly, this is the kind of “strategy” the so-called Sovereign Citizens, including the Bundy gang that invaded Oregon, uses. It’s meant in part to simply cause problems for government agencies.

    Honestly, Utah should just secede from the union. It seems that Utah poobahs, run by the LDS Church, will do anything to stir up problems for the U.S. government (except when the postal service delivers welfare checks, of course)…People like these Commissioners really should be aware that they are laughed at elsewhere in the country and derided for such foolish and childish behavior.

    As the BLM rep said – be specific and you’ll have a better chance of getting what you want.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.