On the EDge: Time for a memorial for our downwinders

Image by St. George News

OPINION – In the wake of the recent 50th anniversary celebrations of bands such as The Rolling Stones, The Who, and, of course, The Beatles, Hollywood is preparing for another golden fete marking the release of the John Wayne film, “The Conqueror.”

Behind the scenes image of John Wayne running Geiger counter over rocks in Snow Canyon during the shooting of "The Conqueror," Snow Canyon, Ivins, Utah, circa 1956 | Image courtesy of reddit.com, St. George News
Behind the scenes image of John Wayne running Geiger counter over rocks in Snow Canyon during the shooting of “The Conqueror,” Snow Canyon, Ivins, Utah, circa 1956 | Image courtesy of reddit.com, St. George News

The film has a special connection to Southern Utah, whose Snow Canyon State Park served as the movie’s location.

The film won’t be remembered as one of Hollywood’s classics.

But it will be remembered for the surprising number of cancer deaths suffered by those who worked on the film. Of the 220 cast and crew members, 91 contracted some form of cancer and 46 died.

The fact was not lost on a reporter for The Guardian, who visited Southern Utah recently to do a piece on the speculation that the deaths were a result of exposure to radioactive fallout that drifted to Snow Canyon from the Nevada Test Site and fell on the beautiful rocks and dunes where they shot the movie.

There are photos of Wayne passing a Geiger counter over the rocks in Snow Canyon. They were hot with radioactivity. It didn’t really matter because Howard Hughes, and his RKO Pictures film company had sunk heavy bucks into the production and, well, in the best show business tradition, the show must go on.

We will never know if the cast and crew’s short-term exposure to the radiation had anything to do with their deaths. We do know, however, that thousands of innocent people who lived in Southern Utah, whose gardens, laundry, schools, parks, playgrounds, churches, shops, homes – you name it – did die as a result of the poison that fell from the sky.

As my longtime friend Michelle Thomas says, if it takes speculation about how John Wayne died to bring more attention to what happened to the Downwinders – those touched by disease or death because of their exposure to radiation – so be it, but what about the thousands whose names were never attached to a movie or who never received public acclaim who lost their lives?

Michelle was one of the principles interviewed for the story.

The reporter described her as “acerbic,” which, after burying so many friends and family members she has every right to be. She was also described as being an “outspoken advocate” for Downwinders. Yep, right again.

She doesn’t pull her punches and has spoken eloquently in forums – public and private – about the plight of Downwinders. She has reduced audiences to tears with her powerful and passionate advocacy.

The Radiation Exposure Compensation Act of 1990 has awarded more than $2 billion so far to more than 26,000 victims of the testing. For a little perspective, that’s nearly half of the number of casualties the United States suffered during the Vietnam War. The difference, of course, is that these were not soldiers, they were innocent civilians victimized by their own government.

The RECA money was only designated for people in a limited geographic area and who were first-generation victims.

But, what about the others? That fallout came down on all 48 contiguous states, stretched into Canada and Mexico, and even reached across the Atlantic Ocean.

We lionize celebrities of every stripe, make them household names, mourn their passing, even if the closest we ever got to them was sitting in a movie theater or listening to their music

But, what about the others?

They too, let’s not forget, were household names to their families and friends, and their stars shine just as brightly in the nighttime sky.

What can we do to honor them in a more deserving manner than as simply peripheral statistics in a speculative story about a movie hero?

We can start by urging Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, who wrote the RECA bill, to work on another piece of legislation, one that will expand the coverage area and extend benefits to the children of those original victims.

We must also stand vigilant and ensure that we no longer develop weapons of mass destruction, whether they rain nuclear death from the skies or rise up as biological killers from the ground.

By doing so, we can divert those dollars from developing ways to kill people to developing ways to save people.

John Wayne had an image as a big, tough guy. He made a career out of portraying heroes on the silver screen.

But, we have had many heroes here among us who go unheralded, whose battles were just as challenging, whose courage was real and not something crafted by a Hollywood film writer.

Their memory must also be respected and preserved.

Perhaps we could find some people inspired enough to build a memorial in front of the Radiation Exposure Screening and Education Program (RESEP) clinic in St. George bearing the names of all of those who received RECA compensation as a reminder that there is still a battle to fight, that they were noble warriors, and that we should honor life and our fragile existence here on the planet.

It could serve as a source of support for the frightened new patients who discover that they were harmed by this noxious fallout and let them know they are not alone.

It’s the least we could do.

Related posts

Ed Kociela is an opinion columnist. The opinions stated in this article are his and not representative of St. George News.

Email: [email protected]

Twitter: @STGnews, @EdKociela

Copyright St. George News, StGeorgeUtah.com Inc., 2015, all rights reserved.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!


  • Brian June 9, 2015 at 10:43 am

    It’s a slippery slope, Ed. First it’s down winder reparations, then it’s slave reparations, then what? My direct ancestors were killed or driven out of Missouri (Haun’s Mill and other places) while the local and federal government did nothing. Should I be compensated for that? How about the families of people injured or killed by illegal immigrants? The federal government is ~directly~ responsible for that (because action on their part would have stopped it). Should they be reimbursed? Or taking it one step further, MANY murders have been committed by gang and cartel members intentionally and knowingly released by this administration through their back-door amnesty. Should those politicians be criminally liable and sent to prison for accessory? The fact is there isn’t enough money on the world to compensate for the bad that has been committed by America, but the there also isn’t enough money in the world to reward all of its good. If you want to honor these victims, embrace transparency (which this administration has a HORRIBLE record of), embrace limited government that stays focused on it’s actual Constitutional mandate, embrace the rule of law (actual blind justice, not the crap we have today), and embrace personal responsibility and actual capitalism (with both actual risk and actual reward, not the crap we have today) so they have the ability to change their lives ~if~ they choose to take advantage of it through hard work and diligence.

    • NotSoFast June 9, 2015 at 12:04 pm

      For crap sake Brian. stay on subject. If you have no pity for the down winders, just say so. If you want the lack of personal responsibility to stay hidden in the closet as well, throw up politics or change the subject.

      • Brian June 9, 2015 at 1:18 pm

        I never left the subject. It isn’t my problem if you can’t the consequences of proposed actions (I’m guessing you thought obamacare was going to be a huge financial success). As for pitying the down winders, my inlaws are down winders and have had 5 of the 7 siblings get cancer, including several that died from it. So I’m intimately familiar with the subject, but that doesn’t mean I think “free government money” should be handed out to their children, and I’m married to one of them! Socialism and marxism are bad ideas, whether you pity / empathize with the recipients or not. It’s been 50 years. If you’ll go back 50 years for repayment of damages then why not 100, 150, or 200? What is left of our nation when that’s over? Absolutely nothing. Do you propose we give back the western US to Mexico, too?

        • NotSoFast June 9, 2015 at 7:41 pm

          I agree with almost ALL of what you said Brain. But we’re talking about personal responsibility here. In this case, the federal government. Preparing for war in this case caused big problems for the innocent downwinder’s. A Socialist government would say ‘Screw those stupid folks for living in that area’. Nobody is looking for a free handout. Just a little help. There are still many around.

  • fun bag June 10, 2015 at 12:35 pm

    gov’t should just hand out free crying towels to everyone. everybody wants a welfare check…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.