Man sentenced in Veyo vehicle homicide case that claimed teen’s life

ST. GEORGE – A man involved in a dirt bike-ATV accident in March that resulted in the death of a Santa Clara teen was sentenced in court Thursday.

Mackay Thomas Stephens, 27, of Brookside, pleaded guilty in 5th District Count to a class A misdemeanor related to the death of 17-year-old Austin Brett McElyea. Stephens was originally charged with a third-degree felony count of vehicle homicide criminal negligence involving driving under the influence of alcohol. The criminal count was reduced as part of a resolution reached between the defense and prosecution in the case.

Along with the reduced criminal charge, Stephens’ attorney, Marshall Witt, told Judge Eric Ludlow that additional sentencing recommendations stipulated that his client serve 90 days in jail, beginning Sept. 3; pay a $1,500 fine; submit to a drug and alcohol evaluation; and be placed on 18 months of probation. The probation would be supervised until the fine is paid off and the evaluation is completed and delivered to the court.

Washington County Deputy Attorney Ryan Shaum, who prosecuted the case, did not object to the recommendations. Shaum said he had spoken with McElyea’s family, who told him they did not want to seek prosecution, as they saw the incident as a tragic accident. However, they also acknowledged the state had a job to do, he said.

“Causation is an issue,” Shaum said.

It was still unclear who may have been more at fault, but Stephens’ intoxication certainly played a role, Shaum said.

According to court documents, on May 18, McElyea had been riding a dirt bike on a trail in the Veyo area when he stopped to make a U-turn. At the same time, Stephens was riding down the trail on an ATV and was unable to avoid colliding with the rear tire of McElyea’s bike. McElyea was ejected from the bike and rendered unconscious. He had been wearing a helmet, but it hadn’t been properly secured and was torn from his head.

A passerby performed CPR on McElyea, which was continued after emergency responders arrived. Life Flight was called in to airlift the boy to the hospital, but he was pronounced dead at the scene.

Utah Highway Patrol Trooper Mike Murphy, who responded to the accident, wrote in a probable cause statement that Stephens had a smell of alcohol on his breath. When questioned, Stephens said he had been drinking. After failing field sobriety tests, Stephens was ultimately taken into custody and charged.

“It was a terrible accident and I live with it every day, and I take full responsibility for it,” Stephens told the judge when allowed to address the court.

Before sentencing Stephens, Ludlow said he would follow the recommendations, but he also told Witt he was willing to recuse himself from doing so because he knows McElyea’s father. Witt said he had no objection to Ludlow issuing the final ruling.

Members of McElyea’s family were present in the courtroom during the hearing and departed after Ludlow sentenced Stephens according to the recommendations provided.

Related posts

Email: [email protected]

Twitter: @MoriKessler

Copyright St. George News, LLC, 2014, all rights reserved.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!


  • Notorious Bo Obber August 22, 2014 at 10:33 pm

    1500.00 for killing a kid? We have a 5500.00 for a cat. I wonder how much the … is getting for her meow
    Ed. ellipsis.

  • G.S.Hale August 23, 2014 at 8:37 pm

    Seems like the drunk gets off pretty easy. Don’t get me wrong live and let live but drinking and operating any vehicle should bear a much heavier penalty. Especially where an innocent was killed. If getting hammered is your thing then there is a proper time and place… that place is never at the controls of a vehicle. And what did he have to trade or bargain with in order to get a lenient sentence? Seems pretty open and shut to me…. He drank….. he drove….. He killed a kid…. He should pay….. and his sentence should be more just….. He should be making license plates and sharing a cell wit

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.