Protest, lawsuit challenge ‘ignominious’ cellphone tower location

Demonstrators hold picket signs at Sunbrook Golf Club to protest a planned Verizon Wireless cell tower, St. George, Utah, March 15, 2018 | Photo by Spencer Ricks, St. George News

ST. GEORGE — Protesting a planned cellphone tower, concerned homeowners braved the rain Thursday to hold picket signs and proclaim “no Verizon on our horizon.”

The demonstration was held at the Sunbrook Golf Club, where organizers raised orange weather balloons to demonstrate the height of the planned Verizon Wireless tower. Community members at the event huddled under umbrellas as they raised their signs and listened to each other speak about how the cellphone tower would negatively impact them.

Bob Routsong, Sunbrook homeowner and protest organizer, displays a poster with reasons why a planned Verizon Wireless cellphone tower would negatively harm Sunbrook Communities, St. George, Utah, March 15, 2018 | Photo by Spencer Ricks, St. George News

The 80-foot high tower is slated to be built just across the city line in Santa Clara, and would spoil the mountain views and lower the property values for homeowners in Sunbrook Communities in St. George, said Menlo Smith, an original developer for Sunbrook and protest organizer.

“Verizon could go any of a number of different places with that tower, but they have chosen what I think is just an ignominious, terrible disgrace of a location for that tower,” Smith said. “It will be the absolutely dominating feature of that entire view zone.”

Verizon’s tower would be in the way of the “iconic” views of Pine Valley Mountain, Red Mountain and Snow Canyon for residents and visitors at Sunbrook, Smith said.

Since the tower was approved by the Santa Clara City Council in August, Smith has now filed a lawsuit against the city for approving the cell tower.

“We’re not opposed to a tower,” Smith said. “We just think the tower should go in a place that is appropriate for a cell tower like that, not in the middle of one of the most scenic views in the Southwest.”

The Santa Clara City Council didn’t have much leeway when it came to approving the cellphone tower though, assistant city attorney Devin Snow said. To get approval to build the tower, Verizon Wireless needed to apply for a conditional use permit — a permit Snow said cities legally must approve if all the conditions for it are met.

Orange weather balloons mark the location for a planned cell phone tower just north of the Sunbrook Golf Club, St. George, Utah, March 15, 2018 | Photo by Spencer Ricks, St. George News

“Cities have very little discretion under state law when it comes to approving conditional use permits,” Snow said. “We didn’t have the discretion to say no.”

After the Santa Clara City Council originally rejected a proposal to make the tower 100 feet, Verizon offered to lower the tower to 60 feet. This proposal was passed by the City Council, but because of federal permit regulations, Verizon would be allowed to raise the tower to 80 feet without council approval.

Even if the city of Santa Clara couldn’t legally disapprove of the cellphone tower, Snow said the City Council could require Verizon to follow additional guidelines that would make the tower appear less intrusive. In the end, Verizon Wireless agreed to conditions to make the cellphone tower look like a water tower, he said.

Santa Clara councilman Herb Basso even suggested making the tower look historical, according to Santa Clara City Council minutes for its Oct. 4 meeting.

A cellphone tower disguised as a water tower would still be a nuisance, said Bob Routsong, Sunbrook homeowner and protest organizer.

“As time goes on, we believe other (cellphone) providers will want it up to 100 feet,” Routsong said. “No matter what it looks like, we don’t want it in our view.”

Neither representatives from Verizon Wireless nor its attorneys immediately responded to St. George News’ requests for comments. Smith said he spoke with workers at the site of the planned tower who told him the tower is supposed to be constructed within the next several months.

Click on photo to enlarge it, then use your left-right arrow keys to cycle through the gallery.

Email: sricks@stgnews.com

Twitter:  @STGnews | @SpencerRicks

Copyright St. George News, SaintGeorgeUtah.com LLC, 2018, all rights reserved.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!

Posted in Local, NewsTagged , , ,

12 Comments

  • mmsandie March 15, 2018 at 8:49 pm

    I. Didn,t think the height of the 2 balloons was bad I live on tha5 side of town closeby, we all wan5bthe tower but wh9 is going to sit all day and look a the tower.. those people are snow birds, travel a lot, play. golf and won,t. be loooking at the tower most of the time.. itsnit like a big water tank in the back yard or power lines.. we have to accept technology..

    • Real Life March 15, 2018 at 9:14 pm

      Lol mmsandie, you need to accept technology and find a decent texting app.

    • 42214 March 15, 2018 at 9:35 pm

      Coude u rpeet dat, didnt finger out wat u sad

  • utahdiablo March 15, 2018 at 9:39 pm

    The southern Utah greed factory is building 10,000 homes and you guys are worried about a damn tower? …oh boy, your gonna love it when southern California is here in your backyard along with the endless traffic and smog….but yes, let’s save your damn Golf course view at all costs

  • jaltair March 15, 2018 at 9:42 pm

    Perhaps somebody with a genius mind and artistic ability could design a tower that wouldn’t be as obtrusive, perhaps they could become works of art! Has anybody approached any of the artists in town? Doing so could bring a lot of joy to a lot of people. Remember the umbrellas in California? Why not something similar for Towers.

  • Travis March 15, 2018 at 10:39 pm

    “but because of federal permit regulations, Verizon would be allowed to raise the tower to 80 feet without council approval” – a fed regulation that benefits a corporation, but ignores the taxpayers. Can Mr. Trump write an executive order taking the power away from Verizon? Would he?

  • Travis March 15, 2018 at 10:41 pm

    @jaltair: On the East Coast we called the “trees” designed to hide the cell towers “Frankenpines”!

  • Mike P March 16, 2018 at 9:33 am

    Come On !! you know the real reason you don’t want the tower is because it may block the view of the thousands of “temples” that are literally in EVERY neighborhood.

  • Lastdays March 16, 2018 at 11:01 am

    “ Just because we drink Geritol doesn’t mean we don’t care at all “

    “ The tower location is not as useful as our Metamucil “

    And so on………..

  • Uncle Lenny March 16, 2018 at 11:11 am

    NIMBY syndrome.

  • John March 16, 2018 at 11:28 am

    You would think the Syrians wanted to build a mosque right next to their golf course… waaah waaah waaah!..

  • kingshit March 16, 2018 at 1:53 pm

    I have a Verizon cell phone tower in my backyard disguised as a 70 foot pine tree ! it’s beautiful !

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.