Deadly choking games and teens; how school districts, police are facing the issue

NOTE: The choking game referred to in this report is in no way related to auto-erotic asphyxiation. There is no sexual element to this behavior.

FEATURE – In November 2014 the Iron County School District launched the first districtwide awareness curriculum in the nation to educate youth about the dangers of the choking game, shining a spotlight on a rarely talked about statistic and creating a ripple of awareness that could save lives.

Watch the video  play-arrow  above.

Opening discussions

Cedar City Detective and now choking game death expert Mike Bleak was the first to declare a choking game death listed on a Utah death certificate. He said he realized that medical examiners were not armed with the knowledge of how to tell the difference between hanging suicides and accidental choking game deaths.

Since 2009, 40 percent of adolescent deaths in Iron County were attributed to the “clean kids’ high,” Bleak said.

Age distrubution of deaths of youth ages 6-19 whose deaths were attributed to the choking game | Courtesy of Mike Bleak, St. George News
Age distrubution of deaths of youth ages 6-19 whose deaths were attributed to the choking game | Courtesy of Mike Bleak, St. George News

“I think it’s the most underreported cause of death – probably in the country,” he said.

Through educating youth about what causes the euphoric feeling when they pass out, Secondary Education Director Jennifer Wood said, the district hopes to dissuade potential victims from trying something as easy to learn as looking up a YouTube video.

“(With) one of the kids that we lost in our district, the YouTube video was on when they found him,” Wood said. “And so, part of our goal is to be a voice to counteract what’s out there on YouTube.”

The curriculum was developed in Santa Monica, California, by the creators of Erik’s Cause, whose mission is: “To bring awareness of the deadly ‘Choking Game’ into the national spotlight so parents and children understand its true dangers and lives can be saved.”

Their website is dedicated to providing educators, parents and children with educational resources and current research to facilitate discussion regarding pass-out games.

According to the website:

75 percent of children who are surveyed have heard of pass-out games, 20-32 percent of those children said they have participated in a choking game activity of some kind. Of those who have tried the game, 82 percent claim they were unaware of any dangers associated with it.

Iron County – blazing trails

The choking game awareness curriculum adopted by the Iron County School District is a nongraphic, age-appropriate, skills-based program intertwined with seventh and 10th grade health programs.

Erik’s Cause founder Judy Rogg is a human resources expert and psychiatric social worker with degrees from Columbia University and the University of California. She is also the mother of a child who she will never again hold in her arms, because of the choking game.

Erik Robinson, 12, died in April 2010. He is described as having been a happy and healthy sixth-grader, a boy scout and an athlete.

Youth who have died as a result of playing pass-out games | Graphic courtesy of Mike Bleak, St. George News
Youth who have died as a result of playing pass-out games | Graphic courtesy of Mike Bleak, St. George News

Rogg, and her colleague Stephanie Small, worked with educators to develop a curriculum that would not introduce “how to play” pass-out games, but would teach youth about how the brain works, what happens when it is deprived of oxygen and offer skills to help them say no.

The program was not an easy sell for the Iron County School District, Bleak said. It wasn’t until there were recent shifts in administration that he, and medical professional Becki Bronson, who is a school board member, finally gained the ear of willing participants.

There is a “not in my town” mentality that permeates the nation making pass-out games difficult to combat, Bleak said. Parents, children and schools tend to be tight-lipped about the topic, which impedes the discussion, he said.

In Iron County the curriculum is a pilot program, Wood said. They are collecting data by way of pre- and exit-surveys and sending them back to the curriculum developers to gauge program effectiveness and track teenage understanding of pass-out games before and after the lessons.

Representatives from other regions, including Washington County, have contacted her to learn more about the curriculum, Wood said.

Washington County – the Catch-22 of awareness programs

All of the principals in the Washington County School District were surveyed about whether they believed the choking game is an issue in their schools, Superintendent Larry Bergeson said.

“Out of 38 principals who responded,” he said, “… 38 out of 38 responded no.”

The issue has not been concerning to Washington County school leaders, Bergeson said, and they are reluctant to implement a curriculum that they feel might introduce the concept to students.

“You can cry wolf and bring attention,” he said “And you can have a lot more, or a lot bigger (issue) about something than if you would if you let sleeping dogs lie.”

some of the names pass-out games are known by | Graphic courtesy of Mike Bleak, St. George News
some of the names pass-out games are known by | Graphic courtesy of Mike Bleak, St. George News

Wood was not contacted by the Washington County School District, she said, but rather a representative of the Washington County Youth Crisis Center which is a Division of Juvenile Justice Services.

“We know that pass-out games happen in our facilities throughout the years,” said crisis center social worker Tami Fullerton. “It’s not a pervasive problem by any stretch, but it happens.”

After attending a recent conference about prevention science, Fullerton said, she learned that preventive information can have the opposite impact intended based on how the information is presented.

The D.A.R.E. program used to use “drug boards” that show pictures of the different types of drugs, she said, but studies have shown that to be detrimental to the goal of the program, raising curiosity in youth where none previously existed.

“Erik’s Cause is amazing,” Fullerton said. “… people have worked hard to create a curriculum that hopefully teaches the skills and talks about the subject in an accurate way without introducing them and exposing them to the behavior.”

It’s a Catch-22, Fullerton said. Educators never want to introduce something dangerous into a child’s life; however, she said, in the case of pass-out games where the first time it’s played someone could die, a proactive approach might be more beneficial than waiting for a problem to arise.

“I know (Erik’s Cause) is working on some research,” she said. “I hope it will be out soon and that it will, kind of, reinforce that it’s being done in a way that works and doesn’t cause harm.”

If that is the case, Fullerton said, it might be something Washington County could find more compelling to implement into their awareness programs. Until then, however, it’s best for them to err on the side of caution, she said.

Suspended animation; brain facts

The carotid artery that travels through the neck carries close to two-thirds of the blood supply that brings oxygen into the brain. Dixie Regional Medical Center Neurosurgeon Benjamin D. Fox said that when the blood flow is interrupted, it causes a person’s brain cells to dip below the line of normal functionality and become suspended in animation, waiting to either die or receive the oxygen necessary to stay alive.

Neurosurgeon Benjamin Fox explains how oxygen restriction affects the brain, Intermountain Southern Utah Neurosciences Institute, St. George, Utah, December 2014 | Photo by Carin Miller, St. George News
Neurosurgeon Benjamin Fox explains how oxygen restriction affects the brain, Intermountain Southern Utah Neurosciences Institute, St. George, Utah, December 2014 | Photo by Carin Miller, St. George News

When brain cells dip past that line of normalcy into suspended animation, Fox said, that is the point that the person with the restricted blood flow will pass out.

Next to the carotid artery is a bundle of nerves called the vagus nerve. Stimulation of this nerve bundle can cause the heart to stop beating and create a heart attack situation.

“Most of the people that are going to die from (the choking game) … are not really probably dying from the brain not getting blood, which is one thing,” he said, “they’re probably dying because their heart stopped and didn’t start back up.”

Also known as flat liner, space monkey, funky chicken, elevator, purple dragon, space cowboy, rising sun, tap out and many other names, Fox said, the free high is akin to the first time a person gets drunk.

Playing the choking game can have negative impacts on memory, coordination and movement, he said. Frequent and continued passing out by choking will cause headaches and red eyes with burst veins and can even cause irreversible and permanent brain damage.

Signs to look for

There were no signs for Rogg to look for, she said, because her son only learned of the game from a friend at school the day before he tried it – for the first time, and that was the day he died.

Bloodshot eyes, frequent and unusual headaches, mood swings, marks on the neck, unexplained injuries, locked doors and knots tied in the bedroom are all indicators the Erik’s Cause website suggests parents look for if they suspect their child may be participating in choking games.

Doodles on notebooks and backpacks can also be a sign to look for, Bleak said; teens engaged in the behavior are prone to doodle some of the more fun names for the dangerous activity.

Educating the masses

Bleak has traveled around the country and to France to teach law enforcement and medical examiners how to use the methods he has developed to recognize and properly label choking game deaths.

“I made the mistake early on, because I just didn’t recognize it …,” he said. “But now that I know about it, it kind of jumps out at you and there are things that are glaringly obvious.”

Mike Bleak presenting information about forensic autopsies versus phychological autopsies, APEAS Symposium, Paris, France, October, 2014 | Photo courtesy of Mike Bleak, St. George News
Mike Bleak presenting information about forensic autopsies versus phychological autopsies, APEAS Symposium, Paris, France, October, 2014 | Photo courtesy of Mike Bleak, St. George News

Bleak said statistics are not a good representation of the actual number of choking game deaths nationwide, because medical examiners have no way to define them forensically.

“Forensically, all ligature deaths look exactly the same,” he said.

When a hanging death is a suicide, Bleak said, there are telltale clues that support a person took their own life. Suicide notes, longtime depression, substance abuse, family history of suicide attempts, or even ongoing relationship trouble combined with an obvious trigger usually accompany the death in suicide cases.

In choking game cases, however, the clues are completely different, he said. This is why Bleak developed a psychological autopsy to coincide with the physical autopsy performed in any hanging death that is investigated.

In order for the CDC to count a choking game death in their statistics, Bleak said, it has to have been reported in the news as a choking game death.

It is important to educate everyone who has closest interactions possible, Bleak said, from parents, teachers and students, to eye doctors, pediatricians, emergency room doctors and medical examiners; it is important for those to know the signs.

Erik’s Cause representatives are determined to get their curriculum in as many schools as they can, Rogg said. With a little education, lives can be changed she said.

“It blindsided and it changed my life forever,” she said. “And it ended his life here on this earth.”

Click on photo to enlarge it, then use your left-right arrow keys to cycle through the gallery. 

Ed. note: Headline, URL revised – first published April 30.

Related stories

Email: cmiller@stgnews.com

Twitter: @STGnews

Copyright St. George News, SaintGeorgeUtah.com LLC, 2015, all rights reserved.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!

Posted in Education, Health and Wellness, Life, NewsTagged , , , , , , , , ,

18 Comments

  • Sapphire April 30, 2015 at 3:07 pm

    I can’t believe the things people do to hurt themselves. Wasted intelligence. Moms stay home with your kids and be a parent. Show them life is a gift! TEACH! Men, take care of your families and spend time with them. If children didn’t need supervision they wouldn’t have laws requiring parents to care for them until they are 18. They are called minors for a reason.

    • AlaskaMamaBear May 1, 2015 at 2:28 am

      Sapphire, sorry to burst your bubble but I am a stay at home mom. My son was a straight A student; played in the school orchestra; was on the school wrestling team; attended church, without being forced, and was a great friend to all…. Kids who are participating know they are loved. What they don’t know is how dangerous this activity is. Plus, until you have known a family whose child has died from participating in this activity, you should not judge. Never say, “My kid would never do that.” Let me tell you right now, you don’t know! I spoke with a fifth grade class and out of about 17 kids, 5-7 kids raised their hands when the teacher asked if anyone had played the game. I about died! One girl actually saved her brother when he was playing it. So, please do not judge parents whose children die. Do you not think we feel bad enough already? Please think before you post. I have missed my boy for 9 years now. He is never coming back. His dream was to go to MIT when he finished high school… He was in 7th grade… Think before you type!

      • Mean Momma May 1, 2015 at 7:52 am

        What a terribly tragic loss. I am so sorry.

      • Sapphire May 1, 2015 at 4:28 pm

        Sincerely sorry for your loss. In my generation people died because of illness (no vaccinations) or true accidents, not trying to kill themselves when left unsupervised for a few minutes. I can’t remember anyone growing up that was obsessed with all the garbage bombarding everyone today. Children need to be supervised more. And parents need to stop making excuses about supervising them. When we saw how nutty the influence in school was, we home-schooled our kids. They have long since graduated from college and have never been interested in all this junk and neither are their kids. You have a sad situation and now I feel badly that your unsupervised son died, too. Like it or not, an adult should have been nearby. A straight A student obviously isn’t smart enough to know better than to choke himself.

      • fun bag May 1, 2015 at 8:34 pm

        it sucks that kids die from this but i just can’t see it being added mainstream to an already crowded list of public awareness campaigns aimed at teens. it’s just too off the wall

    • sagemoon May 1, 2015 at 9:23 am

      Oh, boy. The nice person inside me is telling the feminist inside me to shut up and not engage.

      • fun bag May 1, 2015 at 8:35 pm

        engage! its for ur own good. trust me 😉

    • summergirl May 5, 2015 at 7:16 pm

      Sapphire
      Kids don’t try the Choking game to hurt themselves. They believe they are doing something safe, to achieve a brief high, without doing something dangerous or illegal. Many kids have just gone to bed, then done TCG and died while their parents were in the next room. Did you supervise your kids, by being right next to them 24-7. A straight A grade 7 student doesn’t yet have a fully developed brain-that happens around age 25. Their brain is nit yet able to connect an action to an unknown consequence. So it’s not a result of a lack of supervision or not being smart enough, as you so rudely put it. it is the result of the lack of education about the consequences of TCG. You have a bad situation (lack of knowledge) and I feel bad that you are not educated about the things you comment on. We will never be able to change the fact that good kids sometimes make dumb choices, but we need to give then the Chance to make a wise decision, by telling them the facts about this deadly activity. Please take the time to learn about something you want to share your opinion about. Maybe then you can actually, share something intelligent.

      • fun bag May 5, 2015 at 8:55 pm

        this article has run its course and no one cares what a summergirl thinks. its on page 4 or 5 so let it rest

  • Free Parking May 1, 2015 at 1:03 am

    Hey stupid parents can’t stay home 24 hours a day… Some of us have jobs to go to.. you know like jobs that pay the rent and utilities and groceries and clothing. I’m really happy for you knowing that you can sit on your …* all day and do nothing…the rest of have have a job to go to some of us have to work 2 jobs…..
    Ed. ellipsis: …*

    • Sapphire May 1, 2015 at 4:34 pm

      If you don’t have time to parent, don’t have kids. It is a choice, you know. What is more important… keeping your kid alive?

      • ladybugavenger May 2, 2015 at 11:33 pm

        That’s reminds me of the mom in hurricane that forgot baby in hot car and it died….no charges filed and a $20,000 fundraiser. she failed to keep her kid alive. #fundraiser

      • summergirl May 5, 2015 at 7:17 pm

        Sapphire did you ever sleep when your kids were growing uo?

  • sagemoon May 1, 2015 at 9:12 am

    Good article, Carin.

  • fun bag May 1, 2015 at 3:15 pm

    If your kids are dumb don’t try to blame it on the rest of us

    • summergirl May 5, 2015 at 7:23 pm

      Fun Bag See the comment I left for Sapphire, you could use some education too!

  • fun bag May 1, 2015 at 8:11 pm

    next thing might be the “run across the interstate game” which will be where teens play chicken with cars on the freeway. Teenage pop culture really has reached new levels of mental retardation.

    • summergirl May 5, 2015 at 7:27 pm

      Teens have always pushed the limits . That is nothing new. Your opinion and your language says a lot about you, and that’s nothing good.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.